Via Xaviar at Comixpedia, a discussion by Steven Crowley of Magellan (and other works) on measuring webcomics by the volume of their readers. He breaks it down thusly:
There are probably five levels of readership numbers:
- Stellar: so many you can’t really count them; 100,000+ readers per day; eg Penny Arcade, PvP
- Super: high to very high; 10,000-100,000 per day; examples? I don’t know!
- Maintaining altitude: medium to high; 1,000-10,000 per day
- Limping along: low to medium; 250-1,000 per day; eg my comics go here!
- Hello? Hellooo? Anyone?: nothing to low; 0-250 per day; eg many webcomics
This brings to mind a recurring conversation I’ve had with various creators (normally beer is involved) about readership numbers and who is actually seeing what kind of audience. The question is especially interesting because Kris Straub adds a comment to the effect that he once thought that 10,000 uniques/day was:
the magic number where you could honestly monetize your whole site and draw a (meager) living.
But, with the explosion of webcomics, 10,000/day just isn’t the number it used to be. So what is the number that lets you live off your comics? Crowley’s talking about daily readers here, but given that not all webcomics update daily, monthly uniques might be a better measure (and I have one hard number along those lines available: 3.5 million for PA, as cited by Robert Khoo in San Diego this summer).
For every other webcomic in existence, we have but speculation, approximation, (perhaps involving Project Wonderful), and not a lot of reliable data. One way to find out. If you’re a creator and you’re willing to answer some questions concerning readership numbers and being able to financially support yourself, drop me (that would be gary) an email at this website (that would be fleen.com). If I get a large enough sample size, I’ll send out questions, gather answers, and break out my old stochastics textbooks to do some analysis on it. Results (if any) will be published here in the aggregate (i.e.: I don’t mention your comic/numbers by name, but only as part of a larger population).
This will probably work best if we get a majority of those creators who actually have a webcomic (and its immediate offshoots) as a primary source of income, but I’d also like to see information on as many creators who are “semi-pro” or thinking about becoming pros — I’m extremely curious about where the tipping point between “this is my hobby” and “this can pay my rent and feed my family” sits these days. My interest in this is academic, but for you creators out there, think of this as like census data — a common dataset that you may use as you wish to whatever benefit you can. So whaddaya say? Willing to answer a few questions?