Because The Head Of FIBD Apparently Needs The Info
Hey, Franck? Franck Bondeux? I know that you think that women just haven’t ever made comics, and that your complete dismissal of considering even one woman for inclusion on the list of nominees for the Grand Prix d’Angoulême is therefore just logical¹, but let me help you out a little.
On the very same day that you decide there’s simply no notable women making comics for a lifetime, the cover of Ghosts, Raina Telgemeier’s next book — not due for nine months! — was released along with a brief excerpt. It wasn’t released to the comics press, it was released to Entertainment friggin’ Weekly because she’s that ingrained in the popular culture. But, you know, women haven’t made careers of comics.
Or maybe we could look at today’s announcement of Hope Larson’s upcoming series, Goldie Vance, a collaboration with Brittney Williams. That one ran in the LA Times, the paper of record of the popular entertainment capital of the world … but you can’t think of any women that have made contributions to comics.
Franck? I hate to say this, but you are not very good at your job. I’ll leave it to others to provide the extensive lists of names that support this argument (and seriously, Rumiko Takahashi is gonna surpass Tezuka’s lifetime page count before long), as there are so damn many of them running around today.
Just — just stop doubling down on the stupid, okay? Withdraw the award for 2016, let some other person start transitioning into your position, and they can do better next year. Because honestly, if you give out the Grand Prix this year, you’re gonna have to mark it with an asterisk that notes the severe dumbassery that surrounded this entire process.
Spams of the day:
Find Divorce lawyers here
Is there something that you know that I don’t?
Your name nominated to list of distinguished women of achievement
Seriously, is there something that you know that I don’t?
_______________
¹ In the most fedora-topped sense of the word.
[Editor’s note: the following comment has been edited for American spellings, house formatting, and to clearly identify the comments of our French correspondent.]
A message from the Fleen French correspondent …
* The FIBD published a communiqué telling that they are going to “without removing any name, reintroduce names of female creators in the list of nominees” (via everyone in France including mainstream media; Robot 6 post. Take it for what it’s worth, especially the communiqué is still quite on the defensive in this correspondent’s humble opinion.
* Analysis from Isabelle Bauthian, via Boulet’s twitter; my translation:
Now from the correspondent analysis:
* Gotta concur on the somewhat parochial aspect of the FIDB, in particular your correspondent was not particularly aware of the general importance of EW as compared to, say, Megan Fox Tits Wolverine [Editor’s note: how we at Fleen refer to that onetime exemplar of comics news, Wizard magazine], so he wouldn’t be particularly surprised if the head of FIBD wasn’t either. Not an excuse, but not a scandal either.
* Double checked his comments on Le Monde and Télérama, and yes, he did actually say that in the original French. His comments about Tintin and Pilote are disingenuous, in particular, given that the most late breaking of the nominees broke out in the 90s, while both Tintin and Pilote went under in the 80s.
* Raina Telgemeier (haven’t checked the other female creators you mentioned) may indeed however be of a later generation than any of the nominees; it’s indeed not about creators “running around today” (except, as Télérama mentioned, for Zep in 2004 …). Takahashi-san however would certainly qualify by that measure.
(reread once)
[Editor’s note: Fleen thanks M. Lebeaupin for his reporting, translating, and analysis.]
By Pierre Lebeaupin on 01.07.16 6:20 am
[…] inestimable Pierre Lebeaupin was good enough to leave an extensive comment on yesterday’s post on the dumbassery surrounding this year’s Grand Prix […]
By Fleen: Try Our Thick, Creamy Shakes » From The Fleen Paris Desk on 01.07.16 10:33 am
[…] were a few other things (some of which got displaced by yesterday’s dumbassery) so let’s talk about them, […]
By Fleen: Try Our Thick, Creamy Shakes » In Non-Paris Desk News on 01.07.16 3:53 pm
The above comments are owned by whoever posted them. The staff of Fleen are not responsible for them in any way.